Class 12 Maths, Worked in Full Past papersGet updates
CBSE Board Examination 2023 · Section D · 5 marks

Q32: Is R={(x,y):x⋅yR = \{(x, y) : x\cdot y is irrational}\} reflexive, symmetric, transitive?

The question

A relation R is defined on a set of real numbers R\mathbb{R} as

R={(x,y):x . yR = \{(x, y) : x\,.\,y is an irrational number}\}⁠.

Check whether R is reflexive, symmetric and transitive or not.

Exam answer

Reflexive: 1∈R1 \in \mathbb{R} and 1⋅1=11\cdot 1 = 1⁠, which is rational.

Why?

R is reflexive if (x,x)∈R(x, x) \in R for every real number xx⁠. To show it is not, one real number xx with (x,x)∉R(x, x) \notin R is enough.

x=1x = 1 works, because 1⋅1=11\cdot 1 = 1 is rational.

Watch out: some pairs (x,x)(x, x) are in R. For example x=24x = \sqrt[4]{2} gives x⋅x=2x\cdot x = \sqrt2⁠, which is irrational. That does not help, because reflexive needs every xx⁠.

So (1,1)∉R(1, 1) \notin R⁠. Thus R is not reflexive.

Symmetric: Let (x,y)∈R(x, y) \in R⁠. Then x⋅yx\cdot y is an irrational number.

Why?

R is symmetric if (x,y)∈R(x, y) \in R always gives (y,x)∈R(y, x) \in R⁠. So start with any pair in R and test the reversed pair.

As y⋅x=x⋅yy\cdot x = x\cdot y⁠, y⋅xy\cdot x is an irrational number. So (y,x)∈R(y, x) \in R⁠.

Why?

Multiplication of real numbers is commutative, so y⋅xy\cdot x and x⋅yx\cdot y are the same number. If one is irrational, so is the other.

Thus R is symmetric.

Transitive: Take x=1x = 1⁠, y=2y = \sqrt2⁠, z=2z = 2⁠.

Why?

R is transitive if (x,y)∈R(x, y) \in R and (y,z)∈R(y, z) \in R always give (x,z)∈R(x, z) \in R⁠. To show it is not, one counterexample is enough.

We need xyxy and yzyz irrational but xzxz rational. An irrational number in the middle and rational numbers at the two ends does this.

1⋅2=21\cdot\sqrt2 = \sqrt2 is irrational, so (1,2)∈R(1, \sqrt2) \in R⁠.

2⋅2=22\sqrt2\cdot 2 = 2\sqrt2 is irrational, so (2,2)∈R(\sqrt2, 2) \in R⁠.

Why?

2\sqrt2 is irrational (a standard result). If 222\sqrt2 were a rational number rr⁠, then 2=r2\sqrt2 = \frac{r}{2} would be rational too, which is false. So 222\sqrt2 is irrational.

But 1⋅2=21\cdot 2 = 2 is rational, so (1,2)∉R(1, 2) \notin R⁠.

Thus R is not transitive.

Why?

(1,2)(1, \sqrt2) and (2,2)(\sqrt2, 2) are in R, but (1,2)(1, 2) is not. The rule must hold for all pairs, so this one example is enough to show that R is not transitive.

∴\therefore R is symmetric, but it is neither reflexive nor transitive.

Where this comes from

Chapter 1, Relations and Functions: Reflexive, symmetric, transitive: x·y irrational.

Question type: A relation given by a rule

How to spot it: click to see

Type 2. A relation given by a rule: letters to prove, numbers to disprove

Spot it: RR is given by a condition, such as a≤ba \le b on R\R⁠, and the set is too big to list every pair.

Here: RR is given by the rule x⋅yx\cdot y irrational, on all of R\mathbb{R}⁠. Symmetric holds for any x,yx, y⁠, as yx=xyyx = xy⁠. Reflexive and transitive fail on numbers: (1,1)∉R(1, 1) \notin R⁠, and (1,2),(2,2)∈R(1, \sqrt2), (\sqrt2, 2) \in R but (1,2)∉R(1, 2) \notin R⁠.

Found an error?

Tell us if something on this page is wrong or unclear. Send feedback on this question →